How to Create Author Guidelines for an Academic Journal

Introduction

Author guidelines are the instructions a journal gives to anyone preparing a manuscript, and they shape the quality of everything that reaches the editor’s desk. This guide shows editors how to write guidelines that authors can actually follow, from scope and formatting to ethics, AI disclosure, and a final checklist.

Key points

  • Good guidelines start with a precise statement of the journal’s aims and scope, so authors can rule themselves in or out before submitting.
  • Cover manuscript types, formatting, referencing, and the submission and review process, including realistic timelines and any fees.
  • Spell out ethical requirements, including authorship criteria, conflicts of interest, data availability, and how authors must disclose the use of generative AI tools.
  • Write for the author: plain language, clear headings, a short checklist, and a downloadable template make compliance far more likely.
  • Review the guidelines at least once a year so they match the journal’s actual workflow and policies.

Creating comprehensive and user-friendly author guidelines is one of the most important steps in managing an academic journal. These guidelines serve as a bridge between editorial expectations and author submissions. When done well, they ensure consistency, improve submission quality, reduce editorial workload, and enhance the overall experience for both authors and editors. On the flip side, vague or outdated instructions can cause confusion, result in improper formatting, and discourage potential contributors from submitting their work.

Author guidelines aren’t just a list of dos and don’ts. They’re a reflection of a journal’s editorial standards, scholarly focus, and commitment to academic integrity. As publishing becomes increasingly digital and globally accessible, journals are receiving submissions from a broader and more diverse range of authors. This makes clear, structured, and inclusive author guidelines more critical than ever. They should rest on the journal’s wider policies, which we cover in How to Develop the Policies for an Academic Journal.

This article walks through the key components of effective author guidelines, explores why they matter, and provides practical insights into how to design and maintain them. The goal is to help academic journal editors craft instructions that are not only accurate and complete but also welcoming and intuitive for contributors.

Figure 1. What a complete set of author guidelines covers
Eight parts, in the order authors usually need them.
1
Scope and aims
What the journal publishes, and for whom
2
Manuscript types
Article types, word limits, required parts
3
Formatting
Files, layout, reference style, figures, template
4
Language and style
Language, tone, editing support
5
Submission and review
Portal, review model, timelines, fees
6
Ethics and legal
Authorship, conflicts, data, approvals, AI
7
Submission checklist
A short list to tick before uploading
8
Upkeep
Annual review, easy to find, matches the workflow
Parts 1 to 7 follow Steps 1 to 7 of this guide; part 8 combines Steps 8 to 10.

Why Author Guidelines Matter

Author guidelines do more than inform contributors of formatting requirements. They establish a professional tone and communicate the scope, priorities, and processes of the journal. For authors, they offer clarity and confidence. For editors, they streamline decision-making and reduce repetitive correspondence.

Clear guidelines can significantly reduce submission errors, such as missing metadata, incorrect referencing styles, or non-compliance with ethical standards. This saves editorial teams a great deal of time that would otherwise be spent correcting basic mistakes or chasing authors for missing materials. Author guidelines should sit alongside up-to-date policies; see Updating Editorial Policies: A Step-by-Step Guide for Journal Editors.

From a reputational standpoint, well-written guidelines position the journal as organized, professional, and aligned with scholarly best practices. Especially for early-career researchers or contributors from regions where publishing support is limited, detailed instructions can serve as an educational tool, helping to level the playing field and improve global participation in scholarly dialogue. For the author’s side of the process, see Understanding Academic Publishing Guidelines.

Step 1: Define the Journal’s Scope and Aims Clearly

Every author guideline document should begin with a brief overview of the journal’s scope and aims. This not only sets the thematic boundary for submissions but also saves both authors and editors from wasting time on manuscripts that don’t fit.

Be specific. Don’t just say the journal publishes “research in the humanities”—clarify if it’s focused on Southeast Asian literature, postcolonial studies, or comparative philosophy. The more precise the description, the better authors can self-select appropriately before submitting.

This section can also touch on the journal’s mission and intended readership. Is it aimed at academic specialists, practitioners, interdisciplinary researchers, or a general academic audience? Clarifying this upfront helps contributors frame their work accordingly and supports editors in maintaining the journal’s scholarly identity.

Step 2: Outline Manuscript Types and Requirements

Not all submissions are created equal. Journals typically accept a variety of content types: original research articles, review essays, book reviews, conference reports, and sometimes even creative or experimental pieces. Each of these comes with its own expectations.

This section should describe the different types of manuscripts accepted and their respective word limits, structural elements, and review processes. For example, a standard research article might require an abstract, keywords, introduction, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusion, while a book review might only need a brief abstract and a critical analysis of the book’s content and contribution.

Authors appreciate knowing the approximate length of submissions, whether footnotes or endnotes are preferred, and if supplementary materials (like datasets or multimedia) can be submitted. Addressing these elements upfront avoids back-and-forth communications later in the process.

Step 3: Provide Detailed Formatting Instructions

Formatting consistency enhances readability and professionalism. Author guidelines should cover all the essential formatting details, including file formats (e.g., DOCX, PDF), font preferences, line spacing, page numbering, and section heading styles.

Most importantly, indicate the referencing or citation style required—APA, MLA, Chicago, Vancouver, or something else. If the journal uses a modified version of a common style, be sure to explain the differences or provide a downloadable template.

Authors also need clarity on how to format tables, figures, captions, and in-text references. Should tables be embedded in the main text or submitted separately? Are color images acceptable, and if so, at what resolution? Providing examples or linking to a style guide can be a helpful touch.

Some journals include a manuscript template that authors can download and follow. This small addition can significantly boost the quality and consistency of submissions.

Step 4: Address Language and Style Expectations

Academic writing isn’t uniform across disciplines or regions. To avoid misunderstandings, explain the tone, readability, and language proficiency expected of submissions. Is the journal accepting articles in English only, or does it support multilingual contributions? If so, what are the rules regarding abstracts or translations?

Clarity in expression is crucial, but so is academic rigor. Encourage authors to write in accessible yet scholarly prose, avoid excessive jargon, and provide sufficient background when introducing complex or localized topics.

If the journal offers or recommends language editing services, include a note about it. This is especially helpful for authors writing in a second or third language. Make it clear whether poor language quality could result in desk rejection, and suggest what support options are available.

Step 5: Clarify Submission and Review Procedures

This is one of the most critical sections, yet it’s often underdeveloped in many guideline documents. Authors need to know how to submit, what to expect after submission, and how long the process will take.

Explain the submission portal or email address to use, and if registration is required, walk authors through it briefly. Describe the steps involved in the editorial process: initial screening, peer review, revisions, and final decision. If the journal uses double-anonymized (double-blind) peer review, highlight what authors must do to anonymize their manuscripts (e.g., removing names from headers, replacing identifying details in citations).

Transparency about timelines also matters. While review durations vary, giving an estimated timeframe—say, 6 to 12 weeks for initial feedback—helps manage expectations. If there are publication fees, open access charges, or waivers, they should be clearly explained here as well.

Figure 2. The author’s journey, and what the guidelines should explain at each stage
Authors want to know what happens after they press submit.
1
Submission
How to submit, which files, any fees
2
Initial screening
What leads to desk rejection
3
Peer review
Review model, how to anonymize, typical timeline
4
Revision
How to respond to reviewers and resubmit
5
Decision and production
Proofs, licensing, publication
Stage names vary by journal and submission system. Wherever possible, give realistic timelines rather than best-case ones.

Ethical publishing is the backbone of academic credibility. Author guidelines should clearly lay out the journal’s stance on issues like plagiarism, duplicate submissions, conflicts of interest, authorship criteria, and data transparency.

Include a declaration section where authors must confirm originality, appropriate authorship, and adherence to ethical research practices. If the journal follows COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) or another professional standard, mention this and provide a link.

For research involving human or animal subjects, authors should be instructed to provide evidence of ethical approval. For clinical studies, registration with a trial database might be required. These expectations protect both the authors and the journal from legal or reputational risk.

Two newer areas deserve their own paragraphs. The first is authorship and contribution. Many journals now ask authors to describe each person’s role using the CRediT taxonomy, a set of 14 contributor roles published as the ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022 standard, and to supply an ORCID iD for at least the corresponding author.

Figure 3. The 14 CRediT contributor roles
Ask authors to assign each contributor one or more of these roles.
  • 1Conceptualization
  • 2Data curation
  • 3Formal analysis
  • 4Funding acquisition
  • 5Investigation
  • 6Methodology
  • 7Project administration
  • 8Resources
  • 9Software
  • 10Supervision
  • 11Validation
  • 12Visualization
  • 13Writing – original draft
  • 14Writing – review & editing
Example statementA. Rahman: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – original draft. L. Chen: Investigation, Formal analysis, Visualization. M. Okafor: Supervision, Writing – review & editing.
Source: CRediT (Contributor Role Taxonomy), published as ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022. The names in the example are fictional.

The second is generative AI. In line with the position of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) that AI tools cannot be listed as authors, most journals now tell authors whether AI tools may be used, how their use must be disclosed (for example, in the methods or acknowledgments section), and that the human authors remain responsible for the content. Say the same for reviewers, who should not upload confidential manuscripts into public AI tools. Our piece on writing an AI policy for authors goes into the details.

Figure 4. Six things an AI policy in your guidelines should settle
Clear answers prevent both misuse and needless rejections.
Authorship
AI tools cannot be listed as authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the work.
Permitted uses
Which uses are allowed, for example language editing, and which are not, for example generating data or findings.
Disclosure
Where and how authors must declare AI use, such as the methods or acknowledgments section.
Accountability
Human authors remain responsible for accuracy, originality, and citations.
Images
Whether AI-generated or AI-altered figures and images are accepted.
Reviewers
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts to public AI tools.
The authorship point follows the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) position on AI tools. Permitted uses and image rules vary from journal to journal, so state your own.

Step 7: Include a Checklist for Submission

While this might seem like a small feature, a submission checklist helps authors make sure they’ve included everything needed before hitting “submit.” This reduces incomplete submissions and avoids unnecessary back-and-forth communication with editorial staff.

A sample checklist might include items like:

  • The manuscript follows the required formatting.
  • An abstract and keywords are included.
  • Author information is correctly listed in a separate file.
  • All tables and figures are included and properly labeled.
  • References are in the required style and format.
  • Ethical declarations are signed or uploaded.

Although presented in list format, the checklist should not dominate the guidelines. Keeping it concise and positioned near the end is usually the most effective approach.

Step 8: Keep Guidelines Accessible and Updated

Even the best author guidelines can become obsolete. Referencing outdated software, broken links, or old review policies creates confusion and undermines confidence in the journal. Make it a routine to review and update the guidelines at least once a year, or whenever major changes are implemented.

Equally important is how the guidelines are presented. A long block of dense text can be intimidating. Use clear headings, short paragraphs, and, if possible, a downloadable version in PDF format. Some journals also provide an FAQ section that answers common author concerns in a more conversational tone.

Make the guidelines easy to find on the journal’s website. Ideally, they should be just one click away from the homepage or submission portal.

Step 9: Align Author Guidelines with Editorial and Production Workflows

One common pitfall is creating guidelines that don’t reflect actual editorial practices. If authors are told to format references in APA style, but the editorial team later converts everything to Chicago, it creates inefficiencies. Consistency is key.

Collaborate with your editorial, production, and design teams to ensure that the guidelines align with current workflows. It may be worthwhile to involve the peer reviewers too—some journals include a reviewer checklist that complements the author guidelines, ensuring everyone evaluates manuscripts by the same criteria.

How to create author guidelines for an academic journal - Workflow

Having internal consistency across all publishing touchpoints—from author submission to final layout—creates a smoother, more predictable publishing experience. The same principle runs through our guide to best practices in managing academic journals.

Step 10: Consider International Contributors and Inclusion

Academic publishing is increasingly global. Authors may come from diverse cultural, institutional, and disciplinary backgrounds. Well-crafted guidelines anticipate this diversity and make efforts to be inclusive.

Avoid assumptions that all authors are familiar with common Western academic conventions. Be specific in your instructions and avoid unnecessary jargon. Use plain language wherever possible, and provide examples of how things should look.

Offering translated versions of your guidelines—or at least the main points—can be a significant step toward expanding your author base. Journals that want to attract more global contributors should also provide guidance on writing for an international readership, such as explaining the relevance of local case studies or ensuring data is contextualized for unfamiliar audiences.

See the Guidelines Through the Author’s Eyes

It helps to remember how authors actually use guidelines. Most read them at two moments: when deciding whether to submit, and again just before uploading their files. In between, they are writing, often with co-authors who may never open the guidelines at all.

Experienced authors turn long guidelines into a checklist of the requirements that matter most: word count, structure, reference style, figure resolution and format, and what the cover letter must say. They use reference managers such as Zotero or EndNote to apply the journal’s citation style, and they ask one co-author to do a final compliance check before submission. Editors can support all of this by putting the essentials at the top of the page, offering a template and a reference style file, and naming a contact for questions.

Authors also value knowing what happens after they press submit. Most journals use a submission system such as ScholarOne, Editorial Manager, or Open Journal Systems, where authors upload a cover letter, a title page, an anonymized manuscript, figures, and supplementary files, and then track the manuscript’s status. A short explanation of that process, and of how to submit a revision with a point-by-point response to reviewers, saves both sides a lot of email. For the related editorial task, see how to create manuscript submission guidelines.

Figure 5. One page, two readers
The same guidelines have to work for the editor who writes them and the author who follows them.
What editors need
  • A precise scope that filters out poor fits
  • Complete, consistent submissions
  • Fewer emails chasing missing files
  • Ethics declarations on record
  • Formatting that matches production
What authors need
  • A quick answer to “does my paper fit?”
  • The essentials at the top of the page
  • A template and a reference style file
  • Clear rules on AI, data, and authorship
  • Realistic timelines and a named contact
Good guidelines serve both: every requirement an editor relies on should be stated where an author will see it.
Summarizes the editor’s and author’s perspectives discussed in this guide.

Conclusion

Author guidelines are often seen as a housekeeping task, but in reality, they are a strategic tool that shapes how a journal is perceived and how efficiently it operates. Creating clear, detailed, and well-structured guidelines requires editorial foresight and regular maintenance, but the payoff is substantial: higher-quality submissions, less editorial friction, and a better experience for all involved.

By defining the journal’s scope, detailing formatting and submission procedures, addressing ethical expectations, and making guidelines accessible and inclusive, editors set the tone for a professional and transparent publishing process. In the competitive and collaborative world of academic publishing, that clarity is not just appreciated—it’s essential.

Leave a comment