How to Run a Scholarly Journal

Table of Contents


Scholarly journals play a vital role in academia and research. These publications are the primary means of disseminating new knowledge, groundbreaking discoveries, and innovative ideas across various disciplines. From the natural sciences to the humanities, scholarly journals provide a platform for researchers to share their findings, engage in intellectual discourse, and contribute to advancing their respective fields.

The importance of scholarly journals cannot be overstated. They are the lifeblood of academic communication, enabling researchers to build upon existing knowledge and push the boundaries of human understanding. By publishing peer-reviewed articles, scholarly journals ensure the information shared is reliable, accurate, and of the highest quality. This rigorous evaluation and validation process sets scholarly journals apart from other forms of publication.

Moreover, scholarly journals serve as a record of the progress made in various disciplines over time. They document the evolution of ideas, theories, and methodologies, providing a historical context for future research. By preserving this knowledge, scholarly journals enable researchers to trace their fields’ development and build upon their predecessors’ work.

Running a scholarly journal is no easy feat. It requires a deep understanding of the academic publishing landscape, a commitment to upholding the highest standards of quality, and a dedication to facilitating the dissemination of knowledge. From managing the peer-review process to ensuring the timely publication of issues, editors and publishers must navigate numerous challenges.

This write-up will delve into the art of running a scholarly journal effectively. We will explore the various aspects of journal management, from understanding the different types of scholarly journals to implementing best practices for attracting high-quality submissions and building a reputable editorial board. Whether a seasoned editor or a newcomer to academic publishing, this guide will provide the insights and tools you need to succeed in this rewarding endeavor.

Understanding Scholarly Journals

Scholarly journals are the backbone of academic publishing, primarily disseminating research findings and advancing knowledge within specific fields of study. These periodicals are characterized by their rigorous peer-review process, which ensures that only high-quality, original research is published. Scholarly journals play a crucial role in the academic community, as they provide a platform for researchers to share their work, engage in scholarly discourse, and contribute to the collective understanding of their respective disciplines.

The Significance of Scholarly Journals in Academic Publishing

Scholarly journals are essential to the academic publishing landscape, as they serve as the primary vehicle for researchers to communicate their findings to the broader scientific community. These publications are typically focused on specific disciplines or sub-disciplines, allowing for targeted dissemination of research to experts in the field. By publishing in scholarly journals, researchers can establish their credibility, build their reputation, and contribute to advancing their chosen field of study.

Peer Review: Maintaining Quality in Scholarly Journals

One of the defining features of scholarly journals is the peer-review process, which is designed to maintain the highest standards of quality and integrity in academic publishing. When a researcher submits a manuscript to a scholarly journal, the editor sends it to a panel of experts in the field for review. These anonymous reviewers assess the research’s quality, originality, and significance, providing feedback and recommendations for improvement. This rigorous process ensures that only the most valuable and reliable research is published, thereby maintaining the credibility and trustworthiness of scholarly journals.

Types of Scholarly Journals and Their Target Audiences

Scholarly journals come in various forms, each catering to different audiences and serving distinct purposes within the academic community. Some of the most common types of scholarly journals include:

  • General interest journals publish research from various disciplines for a broad academic audience.
  • Discipline-specific journals, such as Science, focus on research within a particular field and target experts in that area.
  • Interdisciplinary journals such as PLOS One publish research that spans multiple disciplines and encourages collaboration across fields.
  • Regional or national journals showcase research from a specific geographic area or country and are often published in the local language.

By understanding the different types of scholarly journals and their target audiences, researchers can make informed decisions about where to publish their work and how to communicate their findings to the appropriate readership effectively.

Why Run a Scholarly Journal?

Running a scholarly journal benefits academics, researchers, and institutions. By managing a journal, individuals can contribute to the advancement of their field while also furthering their professional development. Scholarly journals are essential platforms for disseminating new ideas and research findings, making them a vital component of the academic ecosystem.

Benefits for Academics and Researchers

Running a scholarly journal allows academics and researchers to stay at the forefront of their discipline. By overseeing the publication process, they gain exposure to their field’s latest research and ideas. This exposure can inspire new avenues for their research and help them identify potential collaborators. Additionally, managing a journal allows academics to shape the direction of their field by selecting and showcasing the most impactful and innovative studies.

Professional Development and Networking

Managing a scholarly journal can also contribute significantly to an individual’s professional development. The responsibilities of running a journal, such as coordinating peer reviews and making editorial decisions, help develop valuable critical thinking, communication, and leadership skills. These skills are highly transferable and can benefit academics in their other professional roles, such as teaching and research.

Furthermore, running a scholarly journal provides excellent networking opportunities. Editors often interact with a wide range of researchers, both as authors and reviewers. These interactions can lead to valuable connections and collaborations that can advance an academic career. By building a strong network within their field, journal editors can also enhance the visibility and reputation of their publications.

Impact on Knowledge Dissemination

Scholarly journals are crucial in disseminating new ideas and research findings to the broader academic community. By publishing high-quality, peer-reviewed articles, journals ensure that important discoveries and insights are shared with researchers worldwide. This dissemination of knowledge is essential for driving innovation and advancing scientific understanding.

Running a scholarly journal allows individuals to contribute to this process of knowledge sharing actively. By carefully curating the content of their journal and ensuring rigorous peer review, editors can help maintain the integrity and reliability of the published research. This, in turn, helps build trust in the scientific community and promotes evidence-based practices across various fields.

Moreover, scholarly journals often serve as a bridge between academia and the wider public. Many journals now offer open access options, making research findings freely available to anyone with an internet connection. By running a journal that prioritizes accessibility, editors can help ensure that important discoveries and insights reach beyond the walls of academia and have a real-world impact.

Essential Components of a Scholarly Journal

Running a successful scholarly journal requires a keen understanding of the essential components that make up its structure and operations. These elements form the backbone of the journal, ensuring its integrity, quality, and impact within the academic community. Let’s dive into the key components that every scholarly journal should have in place.

Editorial Board and Submission Guidelines

At the heart of every scholarly journal is its editorial board, a group of experts overseeing its direction and maintaining its academic standards. The editorial board is responsible for establishing clear submission guidelines, which outline the types of articles the journal accepts, formatting requirements, and the submission process itself. These guidelines ensure that authors understand their expectations and help streamline the review process.

Another crucial aspect of a scholarly journal is its publication frequency. Whether monthly, quarterly, or annually, maintaining a consistent publication schedule helps build trust with readers and establishes the journal’s reliability. It also allows authors to plan their submissions accordingly and ensures a steady flow of new research findings.

Ethical Considerations and Plagiarism Detection

Maintaining the highest ethical standards is paramount in scholarly publishing. Scholarly journals must have robust policies to address plagiarism, data fabrication, and conflicts of interest. Implementing plagiarism detection software and requiring authors to disclose any potential conflicts of interest helps maintain the integrity of the published research.

Additionally, scholarly journals should have clear guidelines for authorship, ensuring that all contributors are properly acknowledged and that no one is unfairly excluded. Adhering to these ethical standards protects the journal’s reputation and promotes trust within the academic community.

Indexing Services and Open Access Options

Increasing a scholarly journal’s visibility and accessibility is crucial for its success. Indexing services, such as Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed, help make the journal’s content more discoverable to researchers worldwide. By ensuring the journal is indexed in relevant databases, editors can expand its reach and attract more high-quality submissions.

Open access options are another way to increase a scholarly journal’s visibility and impact. By making articles freely available online through full open access or hybrid models, journals can remove barriers to accessing research and encourage wider dissemination of knowledge. However, editors must carefully consider the financial implications of open access and ensure that any associated costs are sustainable for the journal.

In summary, the essential components of a scholarly journal—editorial board, submission guidelines, publication frequency, ethical considerations, plagiarism detection, indexing services, and open access options—work together to create a robust and reliable platform for disseminating research findings. By effectively understanding and implementing these components, editors can ensure their journal maintains its quality, impact, and reputation within the academic community.

Best Practices for Running a Scholarly Journal

Running a scholarly journal is no easy feat, but with the right strategies and best practices, you can ensure that your publication stands out in the academic world. Attracting high-quality submissions and building a reputable editorial board is key to the success of any scholarly journal. Let’s explore some tips and tricks to help you navigate the challenges of managing a scholarly publication.

Attracting High-Quality Submissions

Establishing a clear focus and scope for your journal is essential to attracting top-notch submissions. Researchers and academics are likelier to submit their work to a publication that aligns with their research interests. Communicate your journal’s mission and target audience effectively through your website and calls for papers.

Another way to encourage high-quality submissions is to offer incentives, such as fast-track review processes or waived article processing charges for exceptional manuscripts. Consider partnering with academic conferences or societies to tap into their networks of potential authors.

Building a Reputable Editorial Board

A strong editorial board is the backbone of any successful scholarly journal. When selecting board members, look for experts in your journal’s field who have a track record of publishing high-quality research. Diversity is also crucial—aim to include members from different geographical regions, institutions, and backgrounds to bring various perspectives.

Engage your editorial board by involving them in key decisions, such as shaping the journal’s editorial policies and identifying potential special issue topics. Regular communication and clear expectations can help foster a sense of ownership and commitment among board members.

Effective Peer-Review Management

The peer-review process is a critical component of maintaining the quality and integrity of a scholarly journal. Consider using a submission management system that automates tasks such as reviewer assignments and reminder emails to manage peer review effectively. This can help streamline the process and reduce the administrative burden on editors.

It’s also important to provide clear guidelines and expectations for reviewers, including deadlines and criteria for evaluating manuscripts. Offering recognition or incentives, such as acknowledging top reviewers on your website or providing discounts on publication fees, can help motivate reviewers to deliver high-quality and timely feedback.

Publication Scheduling and Consistency

Maintaining a consistent publication schedule is crucial for building trust and credibility with your readership. Set realistic deadlines for each stage of the publication process, from submission to final publication, and communicate these timelines clearly to authors and reviewers.

Consider publishing issues regularly, such as quarterly or biannually, to establish a predictable rhythm for your journal. If you opt for a continuous publication model, ensure that articles are published promptly to avoid long wait times for authors.

Addressing Common Challenges

Running a scholarly journal comes with its fair share of challenges, from managing conflicts of interest to dealing with plagiarism and ethical concerns. It’s essential to have clear policies and procedures in place to navigate these issues. Some key considerations include:

  • Developing a robust conflict of interest policy that requires authors, reviewers, and editors to disclose any potential conflicts
  • Using plagiarism detection software to screen submissions for potential instances of academic dishonesty
  • Establishing a clear process for handling ethical concerns, such as data fabrication or author disputes
  • Providing training and support for editors and reviewers to help them navigate complex ethical issues

By proactively addressing these challenges and having clear policies in place, you can help ensure the integrity and reputation of your scholarly journal.


Throughout this comprehensive guide, we have delved into the intricacies of running a successful scholarly journal. From understanding the fundamental role of scholarly journals in academia to exploring best practices for effective management, we have covered many topics for mastering scholarly publishing.

Let’s recap the key points discussed in this guide:

  • Scholarly journals are crucial in disseminating knowledge and advancing scholarship across various disciplines.
  • The peer-review process is a cornerstone of scholarly publishing, ensuring the quality and credibility of published research.
  • Running a scholarly journal offers numerous benefits, including professional development, networking opportunities, and the ability to shape research direction in a given field.
  • Essential components of a scholarly journal include a diverse editorial board, clear submission guidelines, and adherence to ethical standards.
  • Best practices for running a scholarly journal involve attracting high-quality submissions, efficiently managing the peer-review process, and overcoming common challenges editors face.

Armed with this knowledge, we encourage you to apply the insights gained from this blog post to enhance your scholarly journal practices. Whether you are a seasoned editor or just starting your journey in academic publishing, the strategies and tips outlined here can help you navigate the complexities of running a successful scholarly journal.

Remember, running a scholarly journal is an ongoing learning process. As you implement these best practices, be open to feedback, adapt to changing trends in publishing, and continuously seek opportunities for growth and improvement. You can significantly impact your field and advance knowledge by staying committed to rigorous scholarship, ethical conduct, and effective management.

For those looking to further their understanding of scholarly publishing and refine their skills as journal editors, we recommend exploring the following resources:

  • The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) provides guidelines and resources for ethical publishing practices.
  • The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA) offers insights into open access publishing models and best practices.
  • Professional associations, such as the Society for Scholarly Publishing (SSP) and the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers (STM), offer networking opportunities and professional development resources.

By engaging with these resources and staying connected with the scholarly publishing community, you can continue to grow as a journal editor and contribute to advancing research in your field.

We hope this guide has provided valuable insights and practical strategies for mastering the art of running a scholarly journal. Remember, your role as a journal editor is crucial in shaping the future of research and knowledge dissemination. Embrace the challenges, celebrate the successes, and continue to make a positive impact in the world of scholarly publishing.

Leave a comment