Exploring the Risks of Self-publishing

Table of Contents


Let’s talk about the risks of self-publishing. Self-publishing offers writers an alluring promise of freedom and creative control. No longer beholden to the whims of traditional publishers and their narrow vision of commercial viability, self-publishing allows authors to share their work directly with readers. However, with great freedom comes great responsibility. Without a traditional publisher’s quality filters and visibility boost, self-published authors face risks around quality control, discoverability, reputation management, and more.

Though daunting, these risks need not deter budding authors from self-publishing. Investing in professional services, building an author platform, seeking feedback, and making informed decisions can mitigate potential downsides. For those willing to navigate the hazards, self-publishing offers efficient routes to publication and higher royalties – rewards that, for many, outweigh the risks.

Understanding the Risks of Self-publishing

One of the biggest risks of self-publishing is the lack of quality control. Without the professional editing, proofreading, and fact-checking services traditional publishers provide, it can be challenging for self-published authors to maintain high editorial standards.

Maintaining Quality

Many self-published books contain typos, grammatical errors, continuity issues, and factual inaccuracies that a professional editor would catch. This reflects poorly on the author and makes the book less credible in readers’ eyes. Self-published authors must be meticulous self-editors or be willing to invest in professional editing services. Otherwise, the quality of their work may suffer.

With over one million books self-published yearly, standing out is no easy feat. Self-published books rarely get the same level of mainstream visibility and access to marketing opportunities that traditional publishers can provide. Without a marketing budget or established author platform, self-published works often disappear into the sea of competing content.

Authors may create high-quality works only to see them flounder without the ability to promote them actively and get them into readers’ hands. Building an engaged social media presence and investigating targeted advertising and outreach campaigns is important for self-published authors.

Reputation Management

In the rapid-fire world of online content and social media chatter, reputations can be made or broken overnight. For self-published authors trying to stand out, a few bad reviews or damaging remarks can quickly snowball into a PR crisis. Authors must proactively monitor what is said about them and their books online. They should also build relationships with readers and reviewers to encourage fair assessments of their work. A good reputation will go a long way in establishing credibility amid the risky self-publishing landscape.

Why Authors Still Choose Self-publishing Despite the Risks

Creative Control

Self-publishing allows authors to retain full creative control over their work. Unlike traditional publishing, where editors and publishers can request significant changes, self-published authors have the final say on every aspect of their book. This creative freedom is a major reason why authors choose to self-publish. Authors who feel strongly about preserving their vision without compromise often find the creative control of self-publishing appealing. They don’t have to change characters, plot points, titles, covers, or anything else because of an external party’s preferences. The book remains entirely their own.

Time Efficiency

Getting a book published traditionally can take over a year in many cases. Finding an agent, having the agent shop the book for publishers, negotiating a publishing deal, and finally setting a release date is very time-consuming.

Self-publishing skips many of these steps. Once a self-published book is written and edited, authors can release it on retail sites like Amazon KDP within days. This allows authors to get their work in front of readers much faster than traditional publishing typically permits. This quicker process makes self-publishing efficient for authors who want to capitalize on trends or release timely books.

Higher Royalties

Traditional publishers usually offer authors a small percentage royalty on each book sold, often in the 10-15% range. Meanwhile, self-publishing platforms like Amazon allow authors to earn 60% or more royalties on each sale. While marketing and distribution are bigger challenges in self-publishing, authors who successfully promote their books can earn much higher income over time than traditional publishing deals. This financial incentive draws many authors to self-publishing despite the risks.

Mitigating Risks in Self-publishing

Professional Editing and Design

Investing in professional editing and design services can help mitigate many of the risks involved in self-publishing. A skilled editor can improve the overall quality of the manuscript by correcting grammar and spelling errors, ensuring continuity and flow, and providing constructive feedback to strengthen the writing.

Likewise, hiring a professional designer for elements like the book cover, fonts, and layout is important for making a self-published book appear polished and reader-friendly. Though these services cost money upfront, they lend legitimacy and readability to a self-published work. An amateurish appearance could undermine an author’s reputation or cause readers to make unfair assumptions about the quality of writing before even reading it. Authors should consider professional editing and design services as investments toward producing the best possible finished product.

Building an Author Platform

With millions of books self-published yearly, standing out poses a major challenge. Building an engaged platform as an author is essential for drawing attention to one’s work. This may involve starting an author website or blog, growing a readership through email lists or social media, participating in online writing communities to network with readers and fellow authors, and potentially paid advertising.

Building an organic fanbase over time allows authors to spread the word about a new self-published book to an already captive audience. It also promotes word-of-mouth when early readers share positive reviews or recommend the book to others. Rather than relying on chance alone, self-published authors can proactively nurture their communities of fans to enhance their visibility and viability.

Seeking Peer Feedback

Getting constructive feedback from early readers is invaluable for gauging initial reactions to one’s writing and identifying areas for improvement. Based on their experiences, fellow authors can offer suggestions to strengthen the narrative, character development, pacing, and more. Meanwhile, trusted friends or beta readers outside the writing community provide insights on clarity, engagement, and reader comprehension.

Risks of self-publishing

Their feedback helps writers catch issues before publication, from plot holes and inconsistencies to grammar mistakes. Writers should seek thoughtful critiques from multiple objective sources and consider which feedback is most relevant for refining their work. Having even a small group of peers review a self-published book helps mitigate the risk of publishing something that misses the mark for readers. Their insights vastly improve the quality of the final published product.


As we have explored, the substantial risks of self-publishing must be carefully considered before you jump into this publishing mode. In particular, we highlighted challenges around quality control, visibility, reputation management, and more that self-published authors need to mitigate.

To quickly recap, here are some of the key risks we covered:

  • Lack of editorial standards and quality control
  • Struggles with visibility and discoverability amidst competition
  • Potential damage to the author’s reputation from subpar work
  • Heavy demands around marketing and promotion
  • Financial investments that may not pay off

These are certainly not trivial challenges, but they can be overcome with dedication, strategic planning, and leveraging available resources.

Rather than shy away from self-publishing because of the risks, you should carefully weigh the challenges against this path’s creative benefits. Do your research, set realistic expectations, and have a plan to produce quality work and connect with readers. The self-publishing landscape continues to evolve, with new opportunities always emerging. So move forward, but do so wisely.

For those considering self-publishing, take heart that this avenue enables authors to share their passion with the world without gatekeepers. Believe in your talent and the value of your perspectives. With grit and smart strategies, your writing can find its audience, and your self-publishing journal can be life-changing.

Leave a comment